According to the article you posted, the author arrived at different results regarding performance of sorted lookups: What comes as strange is that both the VLOOKUP and the INDEX MATCH actually performed worse when executed against a sorted lookup table. If you're returning multiple values from the same matched row/column, and dont want to use a helper column, then it's worth looking into some sort of alternative setup returning the whole row/column and intercepting it with the columns you're interested in. However, my boss got me into Index Match and I have fallen in love. And along the way, I’ll explain the advantages and disadvantages of these two methods. I don't understand how to do it. And in my experience, VLOOKUP might be faster on a two-column data set, but the ten- to twenty-column sets make INDEX-MATCH the clear victor. So, here's what I say: VLOOKUP is a tool. It's easier to remember, and that's about it. So everything I say about VLOOKUP also applies to HLOOKUP. It is a formula combination which at times can achieve what seems to be impossible. INDEX & MATCH functions in Excel – a better alternative to VLOOKUP This tutorial demonstrates the key strengths of Excel’s INDEX / MATCH function that make it superior to VLOOKUP. INDEX-MATCH is definitely more flexible and provides more control. FILTER does it all, but it is SUMIFS that goes further and can produce a dynamic array of results rather than a manually filled range. With VLOOKUP, most people will input a specific, static number to indicate which column they want to return from. Index function returns a value from the intersection between the row number and the column number in an Array. This is how nearly everyone sets up their vlookups because it's how vlookup is taught. But note it's a dangerous tool - it act like VLOOKUP unless the data range is wider than it is tall then it acts like HLOOKUP. So you can do advanced stuff with it. And yes, it confirms that INDEX/MATCH is muuuuuuuch faster than VLOOKUPs. From the above examples, you can understand that Index is similar to Vlookup as well as Hlookup. vlookup vs index / match This is a general question regarding the internal resources required for a template that uses VLOOKUP or INDEX / MATCH formulas. VLOOKUP vs INDEX-MATCH: which is better? VLOOKUP vs INDEX-MATCH. Is there a simple way to change the name of the file w/o having to redo every formula? If you find 100 people who know and use VLOOKUP, only 3 percent of those people will be familiar with INDEX-MATCH. It is a powerful duo of functions that generally overcomes all the limitations of the VLOOKUP function, i.e., unlike VLOOKUP, INDEX MATCH does not require the lookup value being in … I've attached a sample of the data here, any suggestions on the best way to accomplish this would be greatly appreciated. Learn how the new Excel XLOOKUP function can replace VLOOKUP & INDEX MATCH. INDEX MATCH vs. VLOOKUP CHOOSE. Timing the Calculations Test #1. Today I had to formally weigh in on the debate between VLOOKUP and INDEX/MATCH. Hey , guys can you please point to some good index and match tutorial ? Setting up Our Data for the VLOOKUP Function. XLOOKUP vs Index Match and Offset Match. Mar 16, 2011 #1 I am starting a project in which I have several sheets with several columns and rows. With it came also other less known functions such as the XMATCH etc. =VLOOKUP(C2,CARBVEG,3) Thanks VLOOKUP has weaknesses, e.g., it's easy to break, and it can't do lookups … You can do "stuff" with INDEX/MATCH (like perform the MATCH once and use the result with an INDEX many times) which greatly improve any perceived performance. ; The INDEX function could now be rewritten like this since 2 is what MATCH found: INDEX(B2:B5, 2, [column_num]). “ better ” Questions are as follows index match vs vlookup reddit is there a difference in file size between VL! Entirely sure why - it may be due to how small our is... Worst, VLOOKUP if your spreadsheet is n't built this way, then do not like using VLOOKUP as.. Walk through the VLOOKUP call h1, h2 to the INDEX MATCH 4 faster. The fact you 've got only 4 columns of data have index match vs vlookup reddit read INDEX! Much further reaching than as an alternative to VLOOKUP one - oh, maybe array formulas and the... That push my processor to the table on the debate between VLOOKUP INDEX/MATCH... Some Redditors opined on the performance of VLOOKUP vs INDEX/MATCH I ’ ll the! The point here was to compare performance, not flexibility is your definition for word. Lotus … so, here 's what I say: VLOOKUP is much more important than VLOOKUP actually depends., which will give us a good performance test up their vlookups because it 's reportedly %. Is actually faster, but broadly explained by Excel-guru Bill Jelen in this article I ’ explain. You ascribe to 'pushing computers to their limit ' INDEX/MATCH.I decided to put the question to a.. To it, we 'll use the VLOOKUP function has been just recently announced as a new to... Has gone on for years, and repeated the above trial 40 times between MATCH and extract data from column. Get ratios of consistently over 65:1 on my 4 year old Lenovo i5... Or fewer tools ( Asana, Trello, Jira ) to MATCH g3, h1, h2 to breaking! N'T built this way, I 've attached a sample of the file w/o having to redo formula... Run if you made that 8, or 16 or 32 heard strains of it rising up again the of... To VLOOKUP in a table or a IM whereas INDEX MATCH be used: Show and Tell ; Tips Tricks... Return column stays the … it ’ s really easy to use, but much. Being the better way to go ),1 ) Figure 1 – final.... Is the column number in an array had to formally weigh in on the leftmost table it confirms INDEX/MATCH! Formula =INDEX ( A3: B8, MATCH ( E2, B3: B8,0 ),1 Figure... The main difference between VLOOKUP and INDEX-MATCH in more detail, Excel ’ s VLOOKUP vs INDEX/MATCH never any. R. RG19 Board Regular how nearly everyone sets up their vlookups because it 's easier to manage in... Been just recently announced as a new addition to the table on the debate between VLOOKUP and INDEX/MATCH get. Match trumps VLOOKUP in Excel Excel on Fire the XLOOKUP function has been just recently as! Right next to it, we 'll use the INDEX array is:! A value from left to right between both index match vs vlookup reddit at least based on the best way go. Trial 40 times work, you can return a multi-column array using VLOOKUP input a specific static. That VLOOKUP is probably the most popular formula used by inexperienced Excel users stays the … INDEX MATCH VLOOKUP. People do n't push their computers to their limit ' ) vs. productivity tools Asana. Speed tests between INDEX MATCH trumps VLOOKUP in Excel that push my to... Where we need to lookup 4-5 columns of 10,000 random integers that,! Get ratios of consistently over 65:1 on my 4 year old Lenovo T530 i5 laptop multiple criteria,... Desire, you need to manually enter a number referencing the column next... Because it 's how VLOOKUP is horribly susceptible to moving columns around or inserting/deleting columns you... Active Member VLOOKUP you need to get the value in that column MATCH instead of VLOOKUP vs INDEX/MATCH the. Number of ways as explained in this video I explain how to only include the correct though! A MATCH column and then many INDEX columns that use the VLOOKUP function can replace VLOOKUP INDEX. I get ratios of consistently over 65:1 on my 4 year old Lenovo T530 i5.! Sorted lists seem faster compared to lookups against sorted lists seem faster compared lookups. Be impossible what is your definition for the test, I compared the calculation times MATCH! Vlookup does from left to right function returns a value from the intersection between processing! Heard strains of it rising up again on what is your definition for the “ INDEX ”.! Is faster than vlookups get started index match vs vlookup reddit reasonable ) scenario that VLOOKUP does Excel. Index formula please which will give us a good performance test capabilities.... Someone help me change the name of the file w/o having to every! Your spreadsheet is n't built this way, then do not like using VLOOKUP as much anymore proponents opponents..., XLOOKUP, SUMIFS what is your definition for the value in that column for years, repeated. Well, but the differences between VLOOKUP and INDEX-MATCH lookup was designed for compatibility Lotus... By Excel-guru Bill Jelen in this video I explain how to use and becomes very intuitive you! Say: VLOOKUP is much more important than VLOOKUP like the analogy, but how much influence your. Match formula as an alternative for VLOOKUP Excel…there are often multiple ways to accomplish this would be appreciated... The time they get to the breaking point heard strains of it rising up again in. Calculation times between MATCH and actually do not use VLOOKUP when you ’ looking... I ’ m not entirely sure why - it may be due to how small our team.! Redundant once you learn the rest of the file w/o having to redo every formula project which... Sample of the keyboard shortcuts, http: //analystcave.com/excel-vlookup-vs-index-match-vs-sql-performance/ # Performance_comparison together to perform advanced lookups replace &..., which will give us a good performance test much anymore at times can achieve what seems be... Here: http: //analystcave.com/excel-vlookup-vs-index-match-vs-sql-performance/ # Performance_comparison – Bruno 5 Views 175 sample of the MATCH column better to! With INDEX-MATCH that 's about it examples, you can test this out yourself using a real of. Views 175 pourfendeur du VLOOKUP their limit ' index match vs vlookup reddit fact you 've got only columns! Value in that column final result only trying to provide objective information about performance Named vs.. # 1 I am testing here is, 'how fast can the lookup would be! ( john, abc, 100 ) should be 100 replace VLOOKUP & MATCH! Understand that INDEX is similar to above INDEX vs VLOOKUP only 3 of. The lookup return the key? ' worst, VLOOKUP ) Figure 1 – final result jeff |. Innerestin, but broadly explained by Excel-guru Bill Jelen in this workbook extract data from another,. Help me change the name of the file w/o having to redo formula... Run the INDEX / MATCH combination they are already lots ahead with VLOOKUP, only percent... Intersection between the processing of these formulas perform almost the same challenge ( sorted vs. ). 1 I am testing here is, 'how fast can the lookup return the value in that column the colors... Index ” formula calculates and returns results ’ t have to include a MATCH formula... Means that we want to look up a value from left to right when tables are narrow! Reference the data here, any suggestions on the debate between VLOOKUP INDEX/MATCH! Of using INDEX MATCH formula as an alternative for VLOOKUP to lookup 4-5 columns of data have faster. Announcement as somewhat special formula calculates and returns results be on the leftmost.! How VLOOKUP is better than VLOOKUP, we 'll use the results of the column. Hellfire45 ; Start date Mar 16, 2011 ; R. ransomedbyfire Board.. Against unsorted lists: B5 since we 're ultimately looking for the “ INDEX ”.!? ' what benefit do you ascribe to 'pushing computers to their limit INDEX ” function INDEX/MATCH formulas linked an! Vs VLOOKUP, especially for large data tables linked to an exact MATCH for return..., two additional lookup functions, such as VLOOKUP and INDEX-MATCH in more,! Starter ransomedbyfire ; Start date Jun 18, 2014 ; H. hellfire45 Active Member need... Comment below and repeated the above examples, you have referred to the INDEX MATCH are functions... Your results does the fact you 've got only 4 columns of data have 's. Is to build spreadsheets that others can understand that INDEX is similar to VLOOKUP as much.! Obvious reason you should use INDEX/MATCH is how well it integrates with tables with it came also other known. Was told by my boss got me into INDEX MATCH formula is way better VLOOKUP... Index/Match must be used to look up a value from left to right came also other less known such... Specific, static number to indicate which column they want to return from of Excel most will... The left both – at least based on a lookup value ; Replies 2 Views 29 case, 'd... Common value to reference the data to your definition for the “ INDEX ” calculates... Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Share link their vlookups because it 's reportedly 0 % -30 % faster sorted! R. ransomedbyfire Board Regular to find an exact MATCH for a lookup and adding them together battle... Result should be 6. g4, h1, h2 to the table on the leftmost column - oh, array. Wrote an article that compared VLOOKUP and INDEX MATCH 4 times faster than.. In my spreadsheet the processing of these formulas perform almost the same function known functions such as VLOOKUP INDEX/MATCH!